mamuzzy: (Atin)
I know the lengths of the bookblogging posts are inconsistent, and I know that at this speed I will never finish rereading and analysing the books. But I just love when something inspires me like this, you know? 

Also I officially renamed the Fandom Fuckery tag to The Fandom Menace. I saw that tag on tumblr and just did what we call public procurement here. :DDD I actually started to collect quotes about Ghez Hokan but I was caught up how he hates the Neimodians and I remembered fandom opinions AGAIN. And this is how this entry was born. Because this is a long entry this is the summary what's this about:

::: On racism in fiction
::: Not everyone is watching from the US
::: When you accidentaly recreate racism in progressive fandom spaces but it's okay because you put glitter on it
::: When you use other cultures as inspiration but you only take the aesthetic 
::: Double standards


⊹˚₊‧───────────────‧₊˚⊹ />Click to expand )
mamuzzy: (Atin)
When I started reading the RepComm books in 2023, these were the rules I followed when I saw the first anti-skirata posts:
1. I DON'T GO TO TUMBLR UNTIL I'VE READ THE BOOKS
2. I DON'T READ ANYTHING ABOUT THE AUTHOR UNTIL I'VE READ THE BOOKS
3. I DON'T READ CRITICS UNTIL I'VE READ THE BOOKS

rant under the cut )

And yes. This was in my chest for years now. Thank you for listening.|| 


mamuzzy: (zee)
 Ultimately I hate this hypocritical attitude that fandom believes whatever the author puts on paper is not the representation of their IRL belief system. UNLESS it's something the fandom hates. Then it's suddenly a manifesto. 
mamuzzy: (Atin)
AND ZEE FINISHED WITH THE BLOGGING CHAPTER 2 YEEYYYY!!! It turned out, my comfort activity for the weekend was reading and blogging instead of mindlessly gaming. 


Yesterday I had a very bad experience on tumblr, because KT came up again regarding the topic of misogyny and I think this also made me bury myself in blogging, because if I didn't, I would have reacted to these posts. I think when I started blogging about the books first time years ago, my primary goal was to find my own answers to these questions as well: is the book really as misogynistic or anti-Jedi as it is said to be? And the more I delve into the English version, the more I come to the conclusion that hating on this book and the author is a community-building event in which I simply cannot and I am not willing to participate just to make people like me or my blog more.

Because the more I read, the more I realize that this book must be read CAREFULLY. It truly challenges your literacy, nothing is spoonfed to you, nothing had to be taken at face value. Narrator is just not present in this story, because the characters are the narrators. Ultimate case of unreliable narrators. 

Also this notion of "women who reads these books will suffer emotional damage" is the most fucking misogynystic take I've ever read. Because you will admit that you find women fragile little things who have to be protected from harmful media, and that is just one step from controlling what media women should read. You want Handmaid's Tale become a reality? This is how you get Handmaid's Tale becoming a reality. 

Anyway. Ultimately I'm here for lorehunting and for the characters, first and foremost. One another reason I moved my metas and bookblogging into this separate blog, because I don't want to be distracted what actually is the thing that makes me interested and invested in these books. 

Ahhh this turned out really ranty, I'm so sorry. But that post really pissed me off. People just cannot be normal about women. 

See you at chapter 3!  
mamuzzy: (Atin)
This entry is a bit more personal than the rest but I wanted to share what eyes I see the world with.

I finished with the dissection of Darman for now, and finally I can head to the next part of the chapter which is introducting the secondary protagonist of the book: Etain Tur-Mukan. 
 
When I first blogged about this section, I went overboard with bashing the fandom. I truly hated - despised - how fandom treated the topic of misogyny, especially that now I remember, at that time when I read Republic Commando, I was working a job that is typically “male-oriented” manual labor job and I had to deal with sexist remarks against my gender from both men and women customers. 
 
My stance is: depicting misogyny in literature is not an act of misogyny.
 
There are ways you can depict fictional women in humiliating and hateful environment that treats them like shit, and there are ways you can depict fictional women in an environment, that is straightout propaganda for "how to be a proper breeding-cattle in patriarchial society".
 
Etain on Qiluura - a very poor rural and definitely not progressive society -, was the most realistic thing I could read. (honestly its rawness someway reminds me of Witcher books from Andrzej Sapkowski. Hmm. Maybe I should do a Witcher blogging too? I haven't read the last two books yet.)

Now to understand my point,

[somethingsomething personal oversharing section about living in a post-soviet shithole where actual life destroying misogyny is still a thing and women divorcing their husbands was still considered a shameful act in the 90s]
 
 
I remember talking about Ilippi’s divorce from Kal on Tumblr and how it was fucking awesome badass move… no one cared? Because the more you head toward the west on the map, the more you think: but divorcing is not a big deal, everyone does that and there is no social consequences. 
 
Now I first read RepComm in 2023, but the first book came out in 2004. Imagine me reading this in a book: Kal is considered a shitty person in his own culture, because he failed to be a good father and a good husband. KT wrote about a culture where MEN got the retribution for failing their family. And Kal didn’t take revenge on Ilippi for leaving him. If you gave me this book in the early 2000’s, I would have considered this the most feminist thing I have ever encountered in fiction. 
 
[RAGE].7zip
 
So uhm. Yeah. Damn I got worked up again. I need to touch grass.
 
And you know what? I think these stuff will become relevant again if not already relevant.
 
Page generated Dec. 29th, 2025 11:19 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios