[GENSHIN IMPACT] Fatui
Feb. 22nd, 2026 02:33 pmGenshin is really great at doing morally grey and complex stories, but sometimes... welll... it's not satisfying. XDD
Decided to finish the character quests in Genshin, because I'm so behind with those. Childe's character quest is the proof that putting a child into the center of the plot make established badass characters worse.
KhmhkhmmTheBadBatchkhmmhhkhhmmm.
He is a soldier in a foreign country making other people's life worse, while also a loving his own little brother and family is everything for him, it can coexist. But making him a major dork while at it... idk. It felt weird. I don't think they really knew what they wanted to do with Childe at this point of the story. He is a psycho, he is a rich kid sugar daddy to Zhongli, he is loyal soldier but also feeling shame about this servitude, a loving overprotective brother who will make a dumbass of himself in front of his subordinates to protect his secret in front of his little brother...
I wonder if this "but he loves his brother!!!" is a way to make player symphatetic toward him? That he is just a guy like everyone else?
But as the story goes, it really turns toward the narrative that these Fatui guys are not actually bad guys. Despite being a Military organization. Despite using diplomatic-guise for coercion and debt collection. And aggressively spreading the Tsaritsa's vision. And Human experimentations. And intimidating locals into submission. And stealing artifacts. And sacrificing civilians for "greater good". And--
EDIT:
so yeah my problem is that Genshin villains are often not commited to being a villains, or at least the ones you get to play as well.
Tartaglia (Childe) was the first villain and he was so badass during the whole Liyue storyline. Until he became a playable character.
Signora? Sexy smart villain. Dead.
Scaramouche? He was interesting angry potato, and as soon as he became playable, he became... idk. I guess Nahida truly tamed him.
Arlecchino being an ally because she didn't want her homeland to be drowned, also being a playable character, and now she is showing more and more soft side. But also it turned out this wasn't even her homeland to begin with.
Capitano? Him being an ally and "loving his land" was made sense, but yeah, dead.
Il Dottore? Megalomaniac intellectual. Absolute fav. Dead. Possibly.
Columbina... I'm biased toward her because she was relatable for me XD But I heard that her story got a massive rewrite too? She became a playable character, and friendship saved her and the whole day. She wasn't even a villain but she used her past connections to the Fatui to help us,
which makes Sandrone also an ally. Who is dead. Sacrificed herself.
So my point is that the enemy is more like now completely the Abyss, and not a Snow-Queen-gone-insane like how I expected. Ehh... given the recent Genshin theories where the story is heading, it make sense, but I don't know if i like it. I need to time to get used to it. XD
Please... don't make Tsaritsa being a playable character XDD Let her remain interesting. But given she is an archon, she will be a playable character...
EDIT EDIT:
So look at this way:
Tartaglia --> HE WAS the villain of the Liyue arc and boss fight.
Signora --> She did trouble in Mondstand, she caused trouble in Liyue and she was the bossfight of the Inazuma arc and died.
Scaramouche -> Villain of the Inazuma and Sumeru arc -> Reformed. But he was the main boss.
Arlecchino -> she WASN'T the enemy of the Fontaine arc. It was the bigass whale from Tartaglia's dreams and a prophecy.
Capitano -> He WASN'T the enemy of the Natlan arc -> Sacrificed himself to save Natlan. The main enemy was some bigass Dragon i totally forget its significance.
Il Dottore -> He was mentioned in several arc, appeared in Sumeru as villain, and main villain after Rerir and boss fight of Nod-Krai. Possibly dead.
Columbina -> She wasn't assigned to any nation, so she never got any affairs to meddle with. So while she had potential introduction as a villain first, in Nod-Krai it was erased completely.
Sandrone - Her fortress and Pulonia was briefly playable. She wasn't a bossfight. She was a major ally and sacrificed herself.
Decided to finish the character quests in Genshin, because I'm so behind with those. Childe's character quest is the proof that putting a child into the center of the plot make established badass characters worse.
He is a soldier in a foreign country making other people's life worse, while also a loving his own little brother and family is everything for him, it can coexist. But making him a major dork while at it... idk. It felt weird. I don't think they really knew what they wanted to do with Childe at this point of the story. He is a psycho, he is a rich kid sugar daddy to Zhongli, he is loyal soldier but also feeling shame about this servitude, a loving overprotective brother who will make a dumbass of himself in front of his subordinates to protect his secret in front of his little brother...
I wonder if this "but he loves his brother!!!" is a way to make player symphatetic toward him? That he is just a guy like everyone else?
But as the story goes, it really turns toward the narrative that these Fatui guys are not actually bad guys. Despite being a Military organization. Despite using diplomatic-guise for coercion and debt collection. And aggressively spreading the Tsaritsa's vision. And Human experimentations. And intimidating locals into submission. And stealing artifacts. And sacrificing civilians for "greater good". And--
EDIT:
so yeah my problem is that Genshin villains are often not commited to being a villains, or at least the ones you get to play as well.
Tartaglia (Childe) was the first villain and he was so badass during the whole Liyue storyline. Until he became a playable character.
Signora? Sexy smart villain. Dead.
Scaramouche? He was interesting angry potato, and as soon as he became playable, he became... idk. I guess Nahida truly tamed him.
Arlecchino being an ally because she didn't want her homeland to be drowned, also being a playable character, and now she is showing more and more soft side. But also it turned out this wasn't even her homeland to begin with.
Capitano? Him being an ally and "loving his land" was made sense, but yeah, dead.
Il Dottore? Megalomaniac intellectual. Absolute fav. Dead. Possibly.
Columbina... I'm biased toward her because she was relatable for me XD But I heard that her story got a massive rewrite too? She became a playable character, and friendship saved her and the whole day. She wasn't even a villain but she used her past connections to the Fatui to help us,
which makes Sandrone also an ally. Who is dead. Sacrificed herself.
So my point is that the enemy is more like now completely the Abyss, and not a Snow-Queen-gone-insane like how I expected. Ehh... given the recent Genshin theories where the story is heading, it make sense, but I don't know if i like it. I need to time to get used to it. XD
Please... don't make Tsaritsa being a playable character XDD Let her remain interesting. But given she is an archon, she will be a playable character...
EDIT EDIT:
So look at this way:
Tartaglia --> HE WAS the villain of the Liyue arc and boss fight.
Signora --> She did trouble in Mondstand, she caused trouble in Liyue and she was the bossfight of the Inazuma arc and died.
Scaramouche -> Villain of the Inazuma and Sumeru arc -> Reformed. But he was the main boss.
Arlecchino -> she WASN'T the enemy of the Fontaine arc. It was the bigass whale from Tartaglia's dreams and a prophecy.
Capitano -> He WASN'T the enemy of the Natlan arc -> Sacrificed himself to save Natlan. The main enemy was some bigass Dragon i totally forget its significance.
Il Dottore -> He was mentioned in several arc, appeared in Sumeru as villain, and main villain after Rerir and boss fight of Nod-Krai. Possibly dead.
Columbina -> She wasn't assigned to any nation, so she never got any affairs to meddle with. So while she had potential introduction as a villain first, in Nod-Krai it was erased completely.
Sandrone - Her fortress and Pulonia was briefly playable. She wasn't a bossfight. She was a major ally and sacrificed herself.